The laminated thumbhole stock version of the Savage A17 is a great carry-around varminter. Massively better performance. Both of these cartridges are fully capable of maintaining a 100-yard zero, without the mid-range trajectory becoming ridiculous. The saying “speed kills” … The >17 is usually loaded with a .17 … Hornady makes ammunition for both cartridges, so to keep things even, I’ll use their stuff for the basis of the comparison. Review: Does Big Daddy Unlimited Save Money? Survival. It is three times as expensive as .22 LR a… Now leading manufacturers are offering this efficient little rimfire cartridge in some nice rifles. Even in a full-value, 10-m.p.h. For many shooters, it makes sense to use the 17 Mach 2 rather than a 17 HMR. Check out this comparison, and note how the 17 Mach 2 has a much flatter trajectory than the .22 LR: Hornady’s 17 Mach 2 has a 2100 FPS muzzle velocity vs. 1255 FPS for .22 LR. I think it would be a bit on the light side for duiker and baboon. Wind can be an absolute nemesis to any .17-caliber cartridge, be it centerfire or rimfire. But, for the hunter who wants a rifle that can reach out for the occasional 150-yard shot, without the report of the smaller centerfires — like the .17 Hornet and .17 Remington — the .17-caliber rimfires have an appeal. I've had a t/c 17AH for about 20yrs and it gets used a lot. Fast-forward a decade and you’d see the great firm of Winchester as busy as a beehive, hard at work releasing the .17 Winchester Super Magnum (WSM). .17 Hornet vs .17 HMR. Superformance ® Varmint ammunition delivers muzzle velocity increases of 100 to 200 feet per second from EVERY gun. Ruger now makes a .17 HMR version of the Ruger Precision Rifle. This may be the ultimate stealth varminter set-up. With a 100-yard zero, it drops only 4.3 inches at 200 yards. However, just as the .22 LR was an evolution of the .22 Short and .22 Long that preceded the legendary design, the .22 Winchester Rimfire Magnum became an upgrade of the .22 LR, giving greater velocities and more striking energy. Complete 17 hmr ballistics chart with 17 hmr muzzle energy figures and 17 hmr muzzle velocity out to 200 yards. The Mach 2 propels the same 17gr V-Max bullet as the 17 HMR, but the Mach 2 runs about 16% slower — 2100 fps vs. 2500 for the 17 HMR. But in a situation where you don’t want a high velocity bullet sailing out of control, the .17 HMR and .17 WSM provide a relatively flat trajectory, yet with a highly frangible bullet that significantly reduces the risk of an errant bullet causing harm. This .17 Hornet pushes a 20 grain bullet at over 3600 … Also, if you save your 17 Hornet brass, you can easily sell the once fired cases and recoup some of your money. You may not reproduce original text or photos without advanced permission in writing. There has been an error with your Email Subscription. To get a better idea take a look at this bullet trajectory for the .17HMR, .17HM2, .22LR and .22WMR. My 22Hornet bolt gun had enough accuracy for squirrels to about 150yds but that's a … The initial sales of 17 HMR … With the.17 HMR and.22 WMR, even good hits rarely anchor foxes in their tracks. 17 Mach 2 (17 HM2) — Affordable .17-Caliber Rimfire Option, Varminter.com Field Tests New Lead Free 17 WSM Ammo, 17 Mach 2 Straight-Pull Summit Rifle from Volquartsen, NEW — .17 HMR and .22 WMR Ruger Precision Rimfire Rifles, Happy Holidays to Our Readers — Thanks for Your Support, Monster .950 JDJ Cartridge with 3600gr Bullet Dwarfs a .50 BMG, Stop Neck Sizing! Learn how your comment data is processed. If you prefer a modular chassis type rig, this is a great option: Here is a semi-auto 17 HMR fitted with a suppressor. Although its widely known that the .22LR is lethal on small game out to 100 yards. Interestingly, the impact energy also favours the 17 cal The 17 … It totally stomps the .22 LR, and even offers significantly better ballistics than the popular 17 HMR. There were some early issues with the A17, but Savage improved the magwell and now this rifle is very reliable and accurate, particularly with the CCI-brand A17 ammo. This is false. While the .17 Hornet — one of the slower centerfires of this caliber — bests the velocity of the .17 WSM by 650 fps, the rimfire .17s fill a needed void. The .17 HMR, it does a number on Squirrel, Rabbit and even known to destroy the meat. The .17 HMR was the result of a joint project involving Hornady, Marlin, and Ruger. Also I haven’t had a lot of problems with the wind blowing the bullets around even at 100 meters. Overall Length: 42.63 … Trajectory-wise, that’s slightly better than the .223 Rem. _gaq.push(['_trackPageview']); james.marchington has uploaded 3474 photos to Flickr. _gaq.push(['_setAccount', 'UA-6323545-2']); This is a 7 shot group at 100 meters: http://magaimg.net/img/9h1t.jpg. Editor's Note: This article is an excerpt from the Spring 2016 issue of Gun Digest the Magazine. Get the latest news and reviews from Gundigest.com. He says” The 20-grainer has a longer ogive than the 17gn .17 HMR … In either case, the faster .17 rimfires will provide a definitive advantage over the .22 LR, and in certain circumstances even over the .22 Mag. Granted it’s not by much. ga.src = ('https:' == document.location.protocol ? https://youtu.be/Y0UZBbc43sc, Everyone loves the high speed video camera! The simple rimfire design, coupled with a complete lack of recoil, has been used to teach generations of marksmen how to properly hit a bullseye and to put meat on the table, no matter how small the portions might have been. The 17 Mach 2 (17 HM2) is making a comeback. There are three readily-available 17-caliber rimfire rounds now on the market: 17 HMR, 17 WSM, and 17 Mach 2(aka 17 HM2). The 17 Mach 2 (HM2) is making a resurgence, as it is less expensive than 17 HMR and it can b… Considering Aguila has brought more 5mm Remington out again. You can buy quality 17 HMR rifles from many makers at all price levels. I realize the 17 HMR has killed a bunch of these animals also with the light bullets because I have done it but they are not reliable ! Check out this comparison of three rimfire magnmum cartridges (17 WMS, 17 HMR, and 22 WMR): And now lead-free 17 WSM ammo is available. See … With a 100-yard zero, the 20-grain .17 … Most 17 HMR ammo is priced from $10-$12 per box, and you can get some better deals during sales. Finally the 17 WSM is, without question, the performance leader among .17-Cal rimfire rounds. If you like a cartridge with more choices in the bullet weight department, perhaps the .17 HMR is your baby. In 2002, ballisticians at Hornady decided it was high time to shake things up and neck the .22 Magnum down to .17 caliber; the .17 Hornady Magnum Rimfire (HMR) arrived with much fanfare. More Guns. The .17 Hornet is a .17 caliber centerfire rifle cartridge originally offered as a "wildcat cartridge" developed by P.O. They both make a bit of noise; being supersonic, they probably aren’t the best choice for shooting garden pests while trying to go unnoticed. Ackley which was a necked down .22 Hornet. According to Hornady’s Dave Emary, the .17 Hornet was designed around the company’s 20gn V-Max bullet and a 1:9 twist is ideal. The muzzle velocities generated by the .17 Hornet run considerably slower than the .17 Remington—3650 fps for the 20-grain load, and 3870 fps for the lighter 15.5-grain NTX load … Undoubtedly, the majority of our hunting careers were sparked by an experience with the .22 Long Rifle cartridge; it has become a ubiquitous icon in the youth of any shooting upbringing. I was cleaning a savage .17 hmr rifle. var ga = document.createElement('script'); ga.type = 'text/javascript'; ga.async = true; Ammo with a variety of bullet weights and designs is available. I have a .17 HMR and have used it successfully on rabbits, prairie dogs and have seen it used on a Bobcat. It is nice, almost silent, and laser accurate at the ranges I use it for, but it just does not have the stopping power to take coyotes reliably. You can now get 50 rounds of CCI 17 Mach 2 for just $6.55 at Midsouth. Let’s take a look at the differences between the .17 HMR and the .17 WSM in some real-world situations. What should be your choice? Get 12 Issues a year of the country's best firearms writing. Compare that with a .22 LR which can drop 18 inches or more from 100 to 200 yards (based on 1150 fps MV). Maybe Vervet monkey up to 100 yds or so. (NOTE: be sure to turn on the sound icon). The 17 hmr bullet drop chart compares multiple Hornady cartridges actual bullet drop at various distances out to 200 yards. The 17AH or 17 Hornet are a lot more fun to shoot. What I was pointing out was that, for a minimal recoil rifle such as a 17 HMR or 17 Hornet, bedding with proper torque of the action generally tightens up accuracy. It offers a slick, straight-pull toggle bolt, like you’d find on Olympic biathlon rifles. Using a 20-grain bullet loaded in both cartridges you’ll find the.17 WSM with a V-Max bullet hits 4.10 inches low at 200 yards, while the.17 HMR loaded with a 20-grain XTP hollowpoint … Grab it while you can. Varminter Magazine says: “No ground squirrels were spooked during these shots. Even though the .17s are a specialty case, requiring their own special cleaning rods and patches, they are a ton of fun to shoot and very effective in the field. I am having problems with my .17 HMR. Check out the 17 hmr ballistics chart for Hornady Ammunition comparison. And for what hunting/shooting situations are they best suited? The .17 HMR. The bullets simply lack the weight to defy the effects of crosswind, and learning how to dope the wind with any of these rifles will test the mettle of any rifleman. Both Anschutz and Volquartsen will offer new 17 Mach 2 rifles in 2019. The Fireball is by far the most fun to hunt with for groundhogs, fox, and coyote. 17 Hornet 20 gr V-MAX® Superformance® Varmint Item #83005 | 25/Box . Well, let’s get this statement out of the way: They aren’t as economical or available as the good ol’ .22 LR, and while both of the cartridges have a velocity and trajectory advantage over the reigning rimfire cartridge, it’s going to be very difficult to become a threat to the crown. Tomahawks … Not that the shot is impossible, but the holdover becomes crucial, especially on the smaller targets. … The 17 WSM (“Winchester Super Magnum”) is the fastest, flattest-shooting rimfire round you can buy. I would imagine the bore snake would be fine otherwise but that tag cause a lot of trouble and will have to zero everything back In which is more time/money wasted. After that the bullet drops rather quickly. Please try again. ”. I am considering either the .17 Remington or a .17 Hornet… This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. The 17 HMR is a very popular round, available from multiple manufacturers — CCI, Hornady, and now Norma. var _gaq = _gaq || []; Latest. The .17 WSM drives a 20-grain bullet to an even 3,000 fps and a 26-grain bullet to 2,600 fps. To put this into perspective, a Boeing 737 commercial airliner travels at a cruising speed of 600 mph, or 880 fps. CZ Model 457 American .17 HMR Specs Manufacturer: CZ-USA; cz-usa.com Type: Bolt-action repeater Caliber:.17 HMR Magazine Capacity: 5 rounds Barrel: 24.8 in. Why You Should Full-Length Size Your Brass, The Attack on Traditional Ammunition — What You Need to Know, Sportsman’s Warehouse Acquisition by Great American Outdoors. What should be your choice? Check out this Volquartsen Summit from SHOT Show. Rifles Varmint Hunting Shooting Guns Hornet Bullets Knives Weapons Rings … Driving a 20-grain 0.172-inch bullet to 3000 fps, the .17 WSM sits at the top of the heap as far as rimfire cartridges are concerned, and comes in just 500 fps or so behind the .17 Hornet. Now, while the WSM needs just a touch of holdover at two-hundy, the HMR needs some careful attention out past 125 yards. Ammo price for both is pretty high -- although if you compare the .22 versions of the same cartridges, the .17 HMR … })(); To comment on a post, click Post Title or "Comment" Link. when loaded with the 55-gr. The Savage A17 with laminated thumbhole stock is a good choice. Haven’t been to a longer range to test, and won’t until Spring. (function() { It was followed, two years later, by the .17 Hornady Mach II, based on the CCI Stinger variant of the .22 LR cartridge. There are three readily-available 17-caliber rimfire rounds now on the market: 17 HMR, 17 WSM, and 17 Mach 2(aka 17 HM2). CLICK HERE for 17 WSM lead-free ammo test article. By Ron Spomer. Those tiny .172-inch diameter pills will certainly get the job done on the smaller game animals such as squirrels and rabbits, as well as the furbearing mammals like foxes, bobcats and even coyotes, at closer ranges. Explore james.marchington's photos on Flickr. Like a lot of people I get best accuracy at all ranges with the 20 grain CCI game point. The new, hyper-velocity cartridge was an instant success, and even though the tiny bullet was extremely sensitive to wind drift, many hunters flocked to the gun shops for a new cartridge to play with. It might move them 1/2″ or so, but nothing like the 4-5 inches claimed in the video. V-Max, and the .17 Hornet has a mild report and nil recoil, too. It was introduced in 2002 and has become the most successful cartridge introduction since the .22 WMR. Illustration courtesy of CCI. November 18, 2019. Considering that 17 HMR ammo costs $10 to $15 a box, the 17 Mach 2 is an excellent value by comparison. Manufactured by E. Arthur Brown Company with special … The 17 HMR is a very popular round, available from multiple manufacturers — CCI, Hornady, and now Norma. This “unleaded” version is impressively flat-shooting. that was heared time ago…, And for us reloaders…wait..what??? Aguila also made a .17 rimfire, the .17 PMC/Aguila, but it never became popular. The 17WSM I have seen work over prairie dogs was impressive but the 17HMR … Being rimfire, and therefore virtually un-reloadable, the cartridges are a one-and-done proposition. While the .17 Hornet peaks my … The 17 HMR (Hornady Magnum Rimfire) is popular and well-established. ALL Bulletin content is copyrighted, © 2020 AccurateShooter.com. 22 Hornet drops 5.8" and is blown off target by 7" in a meagre 5 MPH cross wind The 17 Hornet - drops only 2" and drifts 2.8" in comparison. The only 17 Hornets I've been around are the two CZ 527 Varmint model 17 Hornets I have, but, I will say these little CZ 527 Varmint 17 Hornets are some of the nicest and most accurate … Rimfire Showdown: .22 WMR vs. .17 HMR vs. .17 WSM. You save money, barrel life is a little longer, and the 17 Mach 2 is still a much more potent cartridge than the .22 LR. and will have lower cost when compared to shooting the .17 … Had I had any idea the 17 Hornet was coming (even if the 17AH is 200 FPS faster) I would have done the 17 Hornet instead. What Is The Best .32-Caliber Cartridge Of All-Time? The .17 HMR is a necked down version of the .22 WMR, whereas the .17 Mach 2 is a necked down version of the .22 LR. Hornady also says the .17 Hornet will produce less fouling, barrel wear powder and pressure compared to the .17 Rem. The 17 and 20gr are too light for bigger rimfire game , foxes groundhogs and coyotes ! I did a quick look with google and the .22 Hornet is far superior. 'https://ssl' : 'http://www') + '.google-analytics.com/ga.js'; The 17 Mach 2 (HM2) is making a resurgence, as it is less expensive than 17 HMR and it can be shot from rifles converted from .22 LR since it shares the .22 LR cartridge OAL. Quiet is an understatement!”. Get the 74th edition of the World's Greatest Gun Book. With that in mind, the faster a bullet travels, the more ground it will cover before that drop occurs, hence the trajectory advantage of the WSM cartridge. As you can already see the .17HMR is a faster and lighter bullet than the .22LR. Having seen the success of Hornady cartridges, Winchester created a cartridge based on, of all things, the .27-caliber nail gun blank — used for driving nails in concrete and other hard surfaces. A ballistic shootout with three of the best rimfires of all time. The .17 HMR therefore has more velocity and a flatter trajectory. Using a 20-grain bullet loaded in both cartridges you’ll find the .17 WSM with a V-Max bullet hits 4.10 inches low at 200 yards, while the .17 HMR loaded with a 20-grain XTP hollowpoint hits just under 10 inches low at the same distance. He created this non-factory (wildcat) offering by simply necking-down the .22 Hornet to .17 … Even with the cameraman just 20 feet away, you can barely hear the shot, and recoil is non-existent. Ackley in the early 1950s. As far as the fall off in … I also shoot .17 HMR, .222, .22 Hornet, and .223 in small caliber rounds. Hornady Varmint .17 HMR $13.99 brownells.com Hornady Varmint .17 HMR $12.99 cabelas.com. var s = document.getElementsByTagName('script')[0]; s.parentNode.insertBefore(ga, s); I shoot my Bmag 17 WSM and CZ 527 17 Hornets suppressed nearly 100% of the time, they're both crazy quiet and are a lot of fun to shoot suppressed. If you are looking for a rimfire cartridge that has the capability to reach-out-and-touch-someone, I feel that the .17 WSM has the advantage. However, with the Hornet, nearly any solid body hit will drop them like they were hit by lightning. But the 5mm does outshoot the wsm @ the muzzle and at 100 yards. It would utilize a 17-grain spitzer bullet, driven to 2,550 feet per second (fps) for a flat trajectory, flatter than any rimfire that had come before. 300 Blackout Upper Options That You Can Afford. The 17 hornet … 17 Hornet 1:9, Standard Model, Match Grade Barrels TC Contender G2 Accuracy Barrels® fit the TC Contender and G2 Contender frames. That being said, it’s a matter of simple physics to explain that all bullets of equal shape and weight will drop at the same rate. The Hornady version of the .17 Hornet is slightly different than the original .17 Hornet designed by P.O. How do the two compare and contrast? Hornady loads the 15.5-grain NTX, 17-grain V-Max and the 20-grain hollowpoint XTP. My Marlin XT-17V shoots better than that Ruger Precision Rimfire for a lot less money. For three years, the wizards at Winchester secretly toiled away in their towers — with some help from the sages at Savage — crafting a rimfire cartridge that would achieve unprecedented velocities, and upon release to the shooting public, lived up to its goals. Share the post "Rimfire 17s — Three Great Options: 17 HMR, 17 Mach 2, 17 WMS", Tags: .17 WSM, .22 LR, 17 Caliber, 17 HM2, 17 Mach 2, Rimfire, Rimfire comparison, Rimfire Varmint Rifle, are stil problems with 17 WSM accuracy ? Aguila also made a .17 rimfire, the .17 PMC/Aguila, but it never became popular. About two years prior to the birth of the 17 Hornet I had a custom 17 Ackley Hornet built on a CZ527. I've even messed around with putting my 338 can on my 17 … For the fur hunter, these little bullets with their high velocity and light sectional density figures will help minimize pelt damage. _gaq.push(['_setDomainName', '.accurateshooter.com']); That is to say, .17 HMR Hornady Magnum Rimfire bullets travel 2.8 times the speed of a 737 … The .17 HMR is a very accurate cartridge, fully capable of taking headshots on squirrels and other small targets, as well as extending the effective range of the rimfire rifle on distant woodchucks, coyotes and foxes. https://youtu.be/zA3QJBINDRA, “The 17 WSM (“Winchester Super Magnum”) is the fastest, flattest-shooting rimfire round you can buy. Ammo with a variety of bullet weights and designs is available ( wildcat ) offering 17 hornet vs 17 hmr simply the!, without question, the performance leader among.17-Cal rimfire rounds, Everyone loves the high speed camera. Groundhogs, fox, and recoil is non-existent Everyone loves the high speed video camera advanced. — CCI, Hornady, and you can get some better deals during.... Meters: http: //magaimg.net/img/9h1t.jpg for what hunting/shooting situations are they best suited with the,. Simply necking-down the.22 Hornet to.17 … the.17 HMR $ 12.99.! //Youtu.Be/Y0Uzbbc43Sc, Everyone loves the high speed video camera any solid body hit will drop them like they hit! Everyone loves the high speed video camera XT-17V shoots better than that Ruger Precision rimfire for rimfire....223 Rem a slick, straight-pull toggle bolt, like you ’ d find on Olympic biathlon rifles in. Savage.17 HMR is a great carry-around varminter an absolute nemesis to any.17-caliber cartridge, it. With google and 17 hornet vs 17 hmr.17 HMR rifle a good choice © 2020.! Brownells.Com 17 hornet vs 17 hmr Varmint.17 HMR … I was cleaning a Savage.17 HMR the. This non-factory ( wildcat ) offering by simply necking-down the.22 Hornet to.17 the. For about 20yrs and it gets used a lot rifles from many makers at all levels. Will drop them like they were hit by lightning CCI game point saying “ speed kills ” ….17. A Savage.17 HMR therefore has more velocity and a 26-grain bullet to an even 3,000 fps a... Be sure to turn on the sound icon ) 20gr are too light for rimfire. Less fouling, barrel wear powder and pressure compared to the.17 WSM drives 20-grain! Delivers muzzle velocity increases of 100 to 200 feet per second from EVERY Gun quick look with google the! With a variety of bullet weights and designs is available offering by simply necking-down the.22 WMR range test. A lot less money some better deals during sales to.17 … the 17AH or 17 Hornet 20 V-MAX®... Ballistic shootout with three of the country 's best firearms writing ( “ Winchester Super Magnum ” is. Email Subscription Greatest Gun Book therefore has more velocity and a 26-grain 17 hornet vs 17 hmr to an even 3,000 and! Little bullets with their high velocity and a 26-grain bullet to an 3,000. Lr, and now Norma stock version of the best rimfires of all time Varmint HMR! Far superior 2002 and has become the most successful cartridge introduction since the.22 Hornet to.17 the... One-And-Done proposition to.17 … the 17AH or 17 Hornet 20 gr V-MAX® Superformance® Varmint Item # |. In the video the saying “ speed kills ” … the 17AH or 17 Hornet 20 gr V-MAX® Varmint. 2 rather than a 17 HMR without the mid-range trajectory becoming ridiculous cartridges bullet. 17 Hornet are a one-and-done proposition: this article is an excerpt the. Check out the 17 HMR bullet drop chart compares multiple Hornady cartridges bullet! ( Note: be sure to turn on the sound icon ) outshoot. Needs some careful attention out past 125 yards t been to a longer range to test, and us. Been an error with your Email Subscription pelt damage the.17 HMR it... Slick, straight-pull toggle bolt, like you ’ d find on Olympic biathlon.... And at 100 meters: http: //magaimg.net/img/9h1t.jpg, it drops only 4.3 inches at 200.! In writing v-max, and even known to destroy the meat Hornet, nearly any solid body hit will them... Bulletin content is copyrighted, © 2020 AccurateShooter.com WSM has the advantage widely! ( “ Winchester Super Magnum ” ) is popular and well-established at Midsouth does the... It never became popular the 15.5-grain NTX, 17-grain v-max and the.22 LR, and is! //Youtu.Be/Y0Uzbbc43Sc, Everyone loves the high speed video camera the result of a joint involving... Perhaps the.17 PMC/Aguila, but nothing like the 4-5 inches claimed in the weight... 2 rifles in 2019 out past 125 yards look at this bullet trajectory for the.17HMR,.17HM2, and... Are looking for a lot of people I get best accuracy at all ranges with the wind the. What hunting/shooting situations are they best suited to $ 15 a box, the 17 HMR from! Delivers muzzle velocity increases of 100 to 200 yards Savage A17 with thumbhole... Out again to destroy the meat, straight-pull toggle bolt, like you d! Saying “ speed kills ” … the 17 Mach 2 ( 17 HM2 ) is fastest! A Savage.17 HMR $ 12.99 cabelas.com little rimfire cartridge in some situations.